TSA 2019, Weakening argument question

Hi I’m having a bit of problem with this question and I would appreciate any kinds of help.

The correct answer is E, but can anyone please give me explanation why C cannot be the answer? It’s kind of confusing.

Text:
While it is a woman, Ada Lovelace, who is often credited with originating the concept of software, today’s computer tech-related jobs are held mostly by men. The tech sector must continue to work against factors that inhibit gender equality within it. One such factor appears to be prejudice about women’s abilities to write computer programming code. A recent study of a program-sharing and development website analysed the rates by which suggested code changes were accepted by website users according to the gender of the user contributing the changes. In cases where the contributor’s gender was not made clear on the website, 72 per cent of the suggestions made by women were accepted. In cases where the contributor’s gender was revealed to be female, the acceptance rate fell to 63 per cent.

A) Over the time period the website was studied, more female users than male users rejected suggested code changes overall.

B) Leading firms in the tech sector have undertaken a variety of high-profile initiatives to encourage more women to pursue computer programming careers.

C) No meaningful differences existed between the code changes suggested by female users who revealed their gender on the website and those who did not.

D) Even by modern standards, Ada Lovelace received an extensive education in mathematics and the sciences.

E) Male contributors to the website experienced a similar drop in their code change acceptance rates when their gender was revealed.Preformatted text

1 Like

Option C states that no meaningful differences existed between the code changes suggested by female users who revealed their gender on the website and those who did not. However, this statement contradicts the information provided in the text. The text clearly indicates that there was a difference in acceptance rates based on whether the gender of the contributors was revealed or not. When the gender was not clear, women had a higher acceptance rate, but when it was revealed as female, the acceptance rate decreased. This suggests that gender disclosure influenced the acceptance of code changes, indicating that there is indeed a meaningful difference based on gender visibility.

Therefore, option C cannot be the correct answer because it contradicts the information provided in the text. The correct answer is option E, which states that male contributors to the website experienced a similar drop in their code change acceptance rates when their gender was revealed. This aligns with the information presented in the text, where the acceptance rate for women decreased when their gender was revealed.
Also, the text does not provide information about rejection rates or initiatives undertaken by leading tech firms, making options A and B unrelated to the information given. Option D is also unrelated because it discusses Ada Lovelace’s education rather than the study or acceptance rates.

1 Like